I will start with Iran. By blocking the Strait of Hormuz, Iran has played a winning card and oil prices have shot up worldwide. A deal for the US must include opening up the Strait. I believe that Iran will agree to opening the Strait as long as all other conditions of the agreement are satisfied. This of course, will not make Trump happy, as he is famous for agreeing to a deal and then breaking it, claiming the other side has not lived up to the spirit of the deal.
A lot of other more complicated issues can be worked into a deal. Iran will likely not agree to the total elimination of enriched uranium, but I think they would be willing to settle for enrichment limits along the lines of the JCPOA as negotiated by Obama in 2015. This would require inspections.
So, what could US give Iran in return? Very simply, money. This relates to frozen assets, which Iran claims the US owes them. Iran is requesting the upfront release of up to $25 billion in overseas assets frozen by U.S. sanctions. Of course, the US would like a deal where they open the Strait first, and then the payment is left for future negotiations.
It would be an enormous humiliation to Trump, to make a payment. He relentlessly campaigned that Obama’s payment of 1.3 billion dollars was ransom money. It was not. It was a debt originating before 1979 on military equipment bought by Iran for 400 million dollars and never delivered. The interest on the debt came to 900 million dollars.
The other demand of Iran is a halt to the attacks of Lebanon by Israel. Trump is seriously trying to meet Iran’s demand through discussions with Israel.
So, as I see it, it is all about Trump accepting that none of the objectives of the war have been realized, and to get the Strait open, he has to accept the unfreezing of assets. This comes with terrible political consequences for Republicans who backed the war.
Next is Ukraine. Peace will only come when the political powers surrounding Putin, force him to withdraw from Ukraine. They can withdraw to the pre-2022 borders, and agree that Crimea will be part of Russia as it has been since 2014. The idea of a “buffer zone” will not work, and just be the source of new conflicts.
Putin knows that the Russian private economy is in terrible shape absent of the thriving military-industrial complex, from the war effort. I discussed this in my previous blog. So, for the war to end in Ukraine, requires another humiliation this time for Putin. In fact, if he is forced to withdraw troops, he may be forced out at the same time. There will be no deal that includes barring Ukraine from joining NATO. Trump’s great indifference to help fund Ukraine’s survival, I would say is an additional stumbling block.
This is the way I see it. Money is the stumbling block for peace in Iran. Russian withdrawal is the stumbling block for peace in Ukraine. Trump and Putin will have to accept defeat for the wars they caused and can not win.
Stay tuned,
Dave

